Book Reviews

Your long search is over. You've found the home page of Lee Goldberg - author, TV producer, and charming man-about-town.


Aug 2014

Jesse Stone is Saved

Posted by / in Book Reviews / 13 comments

Blind SpotRobert B. Parker died in 2010, but his characters Spenser, Jesse Stone and Virgil Cole have lived on in new books by other authors. Ace Atkins pulled off a miracle by writing two Spenser novels that could have been mistaken for the work of Parker himself…and in his prime. Michael Brandman’s three Jesse Stone novels were awful, not just bad attempts at imitating Parker, but horribly-written books by any measure. Robert Knott’s first Virgil Cole book, Ironhorse, was a decent western, but unremarkable and certainly not up to Parker’s level (his second Cole book, Bull River, was a definite step up and, wisely, a few steps away from attempting to imitate Parker). And the less said about Helen Brann’s Silent Night, a misguided attempt to finish the book Parker was writing when he died, the better.

Now along comes Reed Farrel Coleman’s Blind Spot, a new Jesse Stone novel. I should admit a personal bias right off — Reed is a friend of mine and I am a fan of his work.  When I heard he was taking over for Brandman, I was thrilled. I had high hopes for what a writer of Reed’s skill would bring to the series and those hopes have not just been met, they have been exceeded. I am sure I am not going to be the first, or the only, person to say that he has saved Jesse Stone. His book is not only better than Brandman’s three Stone books (which isn’t setting a very high bar) but even better than the last few Stones written by Parker himself.

Reed has saved Jesse Stone by embracing the character, not by imitating Parker’s writing style. He’s done it by making Stone his own. He has fleshed out Stone’s world, and his inner life, in so many ways. His first smart move was making the crime story personal, one that goes to the root of Stone’s character, and that allows Reed to reboot the series, to reintroduce the character, his past, and his relationships and tweak them a bit along the way. He leaves the Stone series in much better the shape than Parker left it (and let’s just pretend the Brandman novels were a bad dream, okay?)

The story begins at a reunion of players from Stone’s short-lived time in professional baseball. The reunion occurs at the same time as a murder in Paradise, the small town where Jesse is Chief of Police. I won’t go into a summary of the plot, except to say it gives Reed ample opportunity to explore Jesse’s character in interesting ways.

There are many references in the story to past Stone tales, a gift for long-time fans, but Reed is not pandering to them. He’s anchoring his new Stone in the old, paying his respects but saying “we’re moving on.” Those references to past events and characters are the only nods he makes to Parker. You won’t find any imitations of Parker’s distinctive writing style and banter, something only Ace has dared, and brilliantly succeeded, in copying. Reed wisely writes in his own voice, one tweaked a bit to suit Jesse Stone but close enough to Parker’s sensibilities that it feels comfortable, familiar, and just right.

My favorite part of Blind Spot is how Reed makes everyone human, especially the bad guys, which is not something Parker ever did. The bad guys were often punching bags for either his supremely confident heroes’ fists or their wit, but they were not living, breathing people.

For Jesse Stone fans, Blind Spot is cause for celebration and, based on the final pages, perhaps some apprehension, too…at least until Reed’s next Stone novel.


Please select the social network you want to share this page with:

Did you like my post?

If you did then feel free to share it with your community and friends on Facebook or Google Plus, just click on the icons to share.

  • Laurie

    August 4, 2014, am31 8:48 AM

    This is great news. I look forward to reading Blind Spot. I love the characters in the Jesse stone series. Now, if we could only get the movies made again….

  • Glenn Carson

    August 4, 2014, am31 8:56 AM

    I am a huge Parker fan. JS in particular. Actually, I liked the Brandman novels and will look forward to this new one eagerly.

  • Lee Goldberg on BLIND SPOT | Reed Farrel Coleman

    August 4, 2014, am31 9:23 AM

    […] Click here to read the review […]

  • Laz

    August 4, 2014, am31 10:45 AM

    Excellent review!

    What ever happened to the Sunny Randall character?

  • H. C. Newton

    August 4, 2014, pm31 1:35 PM

    I’m about 2/3 through myself, and the only problem I have with this review is that you’ve covered a lot of what I was going to in mine. I’m going to have to work harder now.

  • Mike Napier

    August 4, 2014, pm31 3:24 PM

    Try reading the William W. Johnstone’s Westerns , or the Marcus Galloway Westerns written for Ralph Compton and you’ll never complain about RBP’s writing, Brachman’s or Knott’s again.

  • John Krill

    August 5, 2014, am31 8:04 AM

    Just pre-ordered the ebook. Have read every Spenser book but only saw the Stone movies so this should be a kick.

  • Robert B. Parker’s Blind Spot by Reed Farrel Coleman | The Irresponsible Reader

    August 28, 2014, am31 6:09 AM

    […] read. Coleman has made Jesse Stone his own, while maintaining the universe that Parker created. Lee Goldberg said that Coleman “has saved Jesse Stone.” Indeed he has, and I’m so happy to be able […]

  • Tim Brooks

    September 29, 2015, pm30 1:02 PM

    You state “embracing the character, not by imitating Parker’s writing style.” and that is EXACTLY why I do not like Coleman’s Stone. Its nowhere near Parker’s Stone. Not even in the same galaxy. Brandman’s Stone was not as good as Parker’s but it was close and he adhered to the true Jesse Stone character the way Parker did. I guess you just don’t get it. I buy the books because I want to continue reading Bob Parker and since he’s dead and apparently has no known hidden manuscripts, I’ll take something reasonably close, which Brandman was. Coleman should just change the name from Jesse Stone into Bob Anderson because that’s really what it is.

    • Robin

      December 9, 2017, pm31 8:01 PM

      I agree. I barely recognized Jesse Stone and the other characters I used to enjoy so much. I’m not interested in this version of Jesse Stone.

  • Jo

    December 17, 2015, pm31 7:25 PM

    I loved all of Parkers books with Spencer and Stone but do not care at all for Colemans Blind Spot story…would not have gotten it if it hadn’t said Robert Parker and Jess Stone on the cover. Dislike it very much.

    • Robin

      December 9, 2017, pm31 7:58 PM

      I agree. I just read Debt to Pay. Jesse Stone has had a complete personality change and it’s not for the better.

  • Karen

    January 23, 2016, pm31 5:38 PM

    A suggestion to Michael brand man and tom selleck…hard to reach. My husband and I own all the Jesse Stone movies and we watch them over and over because of the quality of the movies, the wonderful cast of characters, and we have had others watch them and they have gone out and bought the movies. Now thanks to Hallmark channel they picked up the Jesse Stone movies. But this latest is not up to the quality nor the interest of the others. the previous movie had the police chief and the deputy blown up in their car….so naturally we all felt that this new one would have a continuous story as to what had happened…it not only left that out but most of the characters were not in this latest one…very slow moving and not much story. hope they can get this and write stories to continue one of the best series .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *